Someone just asked me if the energy produced by the human population of Florida would be enough to move the path of Hurricane Dorian, which very fortuitously made an northward turn right before it was about to make landfall.
As a species, we make a lot of heat — both with our bodies and with our activities — and there are a lot of people on the Atlantic coast. But enough to make a difference? My intuition says no, yet no one has done the maths to my knowledge, so let’s do it, just for fun. We’ll take one issue at a time, and then, at the end, compare all the numbers against the energy production of the sun and the effects of global warming.
Human body energy production
First, let’s consider the energy produced by human beings. We’ll use energy consumption as a shortcut to getting this number.
American federal dietary guidelines recommend that the average female should eat 1,600 to 2,400 calories per day and the average male 2,000 to 3,000 calories, but everyone needs less as they get older. To get a single average number to use, we can cut the difference and assume that Floridians, one, don’t lead overactive lives, and two, tend be older, thus requiring less food. That gets’s us 2,000 calories.
Next we’ll have to make one a couple more (heroic) assumptions and a totally bonkers stipulation. One is that Floridians are active enough to convert all that energy to heat (as if!) and two, that no energy is lost to other processes (e.g. production of chemicals in the body). Three, we’ll pretend that Florida’s whole population of 18 million people is lining up on the shore in West Palm Beach, just as Dorian was approaching…
Now we can have fun with numbers! To make them manageable in size, we’ll use energy release over one hour. To make them comparable, everything has to be converted to joules, the standard measure of energy, but I’ll give each measure in watts too since it’s easier to relate to. For example, in one hour a 60 watt incandescent lightbulb will use 216,000 joules (J) of energy. The numbers are about to become unfathomably large…
Average energy produced per Floridian|
– per hour
= 97 watts/hour (Wh)
= 348.67 kilojoules (KJ)
|Average energy produced by all Floridians – per hour||348.67 KJ x 18,000,000|
= 6.276 terajoules (TJ), or trillion joules
= 1.743 gigawatt-hours (GWh)
That gives us some comparable numbers for later. Each and everyone of use is a little heat engine, producing about 100 watts per hour; some more, some less. That’s enough to heat up a small space, all on our own, or if it could be converted directly to electricity, we could light up a pretty powerful incandescent bulb. And altogether, the people of Florida produce enough heat energy — 1.7 GWh — to match an average powerplant.
Then it’s time to look at the energy we produce in other ways — driving cars, cooling houses, producing electricity and so on and so forth. We use tremendous amounts of energy, and Floridians use more than most. Fortunately, this is easier to calculate and requires less guesswork.
In 2017, the state consumed 4 quadrillion BTU (British Thermal Units, don’t ask med why that is used) of primary energy (oil, gas, coal, wind, solar, others). That’s the same as 4.4 exajoules (4.4 quintillion joules, that’s a number with 18 zeros: 4,400,000,000,000,000,000).
Divided by 365 days and 24 hours, Florida thus uses 0.5 petajoules (PJ) per hour, or 500 trillion joules. In more familiar terms, that’s 139 GWh, and most of this energy comes from fossil fuels. We’ll assume that all of this energy sooner or later dissipates as heat energy.
I bet your head is spinning now.
|Total energy consumption – per year||4,400 quadrillion BTU|
= 4.4 exajoules (EJ), or 4.4 quintillion joules
|Total energy consumption – per hour||
4.4 EJ / 365 / 24|
= 0.5 PJ
= 500 TJ
= 139 GWh
I haven’t discovered how much energy Hurricane Dorian contains, now or at its strongest. According to NOAA, the average hurricane produces energy in two ways. One is the condensation and vertical movement of air and water; the other through is wind or horizontal movement of air and water rotating air around the eye of the hurricane. An average hurricane is defined as having a radius of 665 kilometres, or 413 miles. Dorian is an average hurricane.
|Condensation energy – per day||52,000,000,000,000,000,000 J (that’s 19 zeros)|
= 52 EJ
|Condensation energy – per hour||2.167 EJ|
|Wind energy – per day||130,000,000,000,000,000 J (12 zeros)|
= 0.130 EJ
|Wind energy – per hour||0.005 EJ|
|Total hurricane energy – hour||2.172 EJ|
= 603,333 GWh
= 603 terawatt-hours (TWh)
In just one hour, an average hurricane produces 603 TWh — a totally mindboggling amount of energy!
For comparison, that’s 350,000 times the amount of energy Florida can consume in one hour — and we know they’re trying hard! In fact, it takes the entire United States 73 days to consume the amount of energy a hurricane releases in just one hour.
Can we move a hurricane?
Finally we can answer the big question. Do human activities have any chance of moving a hurricane or even affecting it a little bit?
Let’s examine the numbers again.
Florida vs hurricane energy comparison:
|Energy released, per hour||Value|
|Human energy||6.276 TJ|
|Total energy||500 TJ|
|Hurricane energy||2.172 EJ|
And by orders of magnitude, in joules:
|Energy released, per hour||Value|
|Human energy produced||6,276,000,000,000 J|
|Total energy consumed||500,000,000,000,000 J|
|Hurricane energy||2,172,000,000,000,000,000 J|
If we look at the sheer size of the numbers, there’s no contest — three orders of magnitude separate the energy released by humans and hurricanes.
Standing packed together in West Palm Beach, all the people of Florida would give up a fair bit of heat, enough to make a slight local high pressure field, as hot air expands. Perhaps a few metres into the air, and covering a small area — let’s give them 1.5 square miles, or 2.6 square kilometres.
A hurricane is a low pressure system covering thousands of square miles/kilometres thousands of metres/yards into the sky. In terms of its energy release, the human population is a butterfly in a, well, hurricane.
But we do move hurricanes!
Nevertheless, there are two ways that we human animals are having an effect on the weather: through land use, and through global warming. Land-use change is a big topic, but in general, agriculture and urbanization have led to enormous changes of the Earth’s surface. Cutting down forests generally cause land-areas to become warmer. This will have to be a topic for another time.
We’ll look instead on the effects of global warming: how much more energy the Earth is receiving — and keeping — compared to before the industrial revolution
The effect of greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) is to increase the amount of energy from the sun that is trapped in the atmosphere. We want a certain amount of GHGs — without them, it would be very cold here. Yet now we’re starting to get too much. Since the first industrial revolution, the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has increased by almost 50%.
The extra energy trapped by GHGs amounts to about 3.1 watts per square metre, or or 0.29 watts per square foot. Not a lot, but we have a lot of square feet!
Florida, for example, has more than 1.8 trillion, or 65,620 square miles (170,000 square kilometres). If we do the math on that, then the state of Florida traps 527 gigawatts per hour more today than 250 years ago. In joules, that’s an additional 1.9 petajoules of energy per hour — a number that is becoming comparable with the energy released by hurricanes. This is just counting Florida, not the vast areas of the Atlantic Ocean where the hurricanes spawn. That’s a lot of extra energy hurricanes and other weather systems can draw on.
How exactly this energy affects hurricane development and trajectories is complex, but one known effect is to make hurricanes wetter, containing more water. And more condensation means hurricanes with vastly more energy!
So there you have it! Comparing raw numbers, I think we need to strongly suspect that human energy production does not have a direct effect on hurricane paths. But the GHGs we produce as a biproduct of all this energy use creates global warming, and that is adding enormous amounts of energy to the planet.
Picture credit: NOAA Environmental Visualization Laboratory